kulawrKutafin Law ReviewKutafin Law Review2713-05252713-0533MSAL10.17803/2313-5395.2021.2.16.199-225kulawr-125Research ArticleRESEARCH ARTICLESSustainable Development of Rural Areas of the Russian State as a Strategic Task and its Legal SupportVoroninaN. P.

Natalia P. Voronina - Dr. Sci. (Law), Professor, Department of Environmental and Natural Resources Law

Sadovaya-Kudrinskaya St., 9, Moscow 125993

nvoroninamgua@yandex.ruMilovidovaA. I.

Alla I. Milovidova - Cand. Sci. (Philology), Associate Professor, Department of Legal Translation

Sadovaya-Kudrinskaya St., 9, Moscow 125993

aimilovidova@msal.ruKutafin Moscow State Law University (MSAL)Russian Federation20210307202182199225Copyright © Voronina N.P., Milovidova A.I., 20212021Voronina N.P., Milovidova A.I.Voronina N.P., Milovidova A.I.Данная работа распространяется под лицензией Creative Commons Attribution 4.0.This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.https://kulawr.msal.ru/jour/article/view/125

Systemic economic, environmental and social problems of rural areas in modern world make the issue of public policy for their sustainable development particularly topical. The socioeconomic development of the Russian Federation, increased volumes of agricultural output, growing efficiency of the agricultural sector, full employment of the rural population and improving its living conditions, as well as achieving efficient land use require proper legal support. The main strategic planning documents regulating aspects of sustainable development of rural areas are represented by three groups of political and legal acts regarding their: 1) agricultural development, 2) sustainable development, 3) spatial development. Most research articles cover one of these aspects of facilitating the development of rural areas. The sources demonstrate the lack of comprehensive legal studies covering the issues of sustainable development of rural areas. The present article provides a comprehensive analysis of the legal regulation of facilitating sustainable development of rural areas in each of the aspects mentioned. The methods of comparative analysis and legal hermeneutics applied made it possible to reveal contradictions and gaps in the strategic planning documents. This precludes the possibility of specifying a single conceptual model of legal regulation of sustainable development of rural areas. The authors have considered the internal and external sides of the model of legal regulation, outlined the legal approaches to its formation in modern geopolitical, economic and social conditions. The article identifies the problems of legal support for sustainable development of rural areas and considers ways to solve them.

rural areassustainable developmentstrategic planningorganic agriculturerural tourismReferencesAndrichenko, L.V., Baranchikova, M.M., Belikova, K.M., et al., (2018). State and legal foundations of the accelerated development of the Russian Far East. IZiSP. P. 301. (In Russ.)Andrichenko, L.V., Baranchikova, M.M., Belikova, K.M., et al., (2018). State and legal foundations of the accelerated development of the Russian Far East. IZiSP. P. 301. (In Russ.)Avarskiy, N. and Taran, V., (2018). Topical issues of improvement of the legislation in the sphere of production and turnover of organic production in the Russian Federation. Ecological Security in AIC, 10, pp. 83–98. (In Russ.)Avarskiy, N. and Taran, V., (2018). Topical issues of improvement of the legislation in the sphere of production and turnover of organic production in the Russian Federation. Ecological Security in AIC, 10, pp. 83–98. (In Russ.)Baldanov, A., Kiminami, L. and Furuzawa, S., (2019). Study on the relationships between rural and agricultural development and human resource development in Russian Federation since 2000s. Letters in spatial and resource sciences, 12(2), pp. 87–100, doi: 10.1007/s12076- 019-00228-y. (In Russ.)Baldanov, A., Kiminami, L. and Furuzawa, S., (2019). Study on the relationships between rural and agricultural development and human resource development in Russian Federation since 2000s. Letters in spatial and resource sciences, 12(2), pp. 87–100, doi: 10.1007/s12076- 019-00228-y. (In Russ.)Bitkova, L.A., (2019). On the issue of rural tourism in Russia: theoretical and legal aspect. Analytical Bulletin of the Federation Council of the Federal Assembly of the Russian Federation, 5, pp. 33– 36. (In Russ.)Bitkova, L.A., (2019). On the issue of rural tourism in Russia: theoretical and legal aspect. Analytical Bulletin of the Federation Council of the Federal Assembly of the Russian Federation, 5, pp. 33– 36. (In Russ.)Bondarenko, L.V., (2019). Sustainable Rural Development: Problems and Solutions. Analytical Bulletin of the Federation Council of the Federal Assembly of the Russian Federation, 5 (719), pp. 13–17. (In Russ.)Bondarenko, L.V., (2019). Sustainable Rural Development: Problems and Solutions. Analytical Bulletin of the Federation Council of the Federal Assembly of the Russian Federation, 5 (719), pp. 13–17. (In Russ.)Burak, M.L., (2014). Organic agriculture — a new model of the agricultural industry. The International Technical-Economic Journal, 4, pp. 45. (In Russ.)Burak, M.L., (2014). Organic agriculture — a new model of the agricultural industry. The International Technical-Economic Journal, 4, pp. 45. (In Russ.)Chetvertakov, I.M. and Chetvertakova, V.P., (2018). Tendencies and prospects of the Russian agriculture development. Turkish online journal of design art and communication, 8(SI), pp. 410–418, doi: 10.7456/1080MSE/148. (In Russ.)Chetvertakov, I.M. and Chetvertakova, V.P., (2018). Tendencies and prospects of the Russian agriculture development. Turkish online journal of design art and communication, 8(SI), pp. 410–418, doi: 10.7456/1080MSE/148. (In Russ.)Galinovskaya, E.A., (2006). On the Concept of the Federal Law “On the regulation of property relations arising during the privatization of agricultural land”. Environmental law, 1, p. 19. (In Russ.)Galinovskaya, E.A., (2006). On the Concept of the Federal Law “On the regulation of property relations arising during the privatization of agricultural land”. Environmental law, 1, p. 19. (In Russ.)Kondolskaya, A., Vasilieva, D. and Parsova, V., (2019). Problems of conservation and use of agricultural land in urban agglomerations. In: Malinovska, L. and Osadcuks, V. (eds.) Proceedings of 18th International Scientific Conference on Engineering for Rural Development (ERD). Engineering for Rural Development, pp. 774–779, doi: 10.22616/ ERDev2019.18.N108. (In Russ.)Kondolskaya, A., Vasilieva, D. and Parsova, V., (2019). Problems of conservation and use of agricultural land in urban agglomerations. In: Malinovska, L. and Osadcuks, V. (eds.) Proceedings of 18th International Scientific Conference on Engineering for Rural Development (ERD). Engineering for Rural Development, pp. 774–779, doi: 10.22616/ ERDev2019.18.N108. (In Russ.)Kuzminov, I., Gokhberg, L., Thurner, T. and Khabirova, E., (2018). The Current State of the Russian Agricultural Sector. Eurochoices, 17(1), pp. 52–57, doi: 10.1111/1746-692X.12184. (In Russ.)Kuzminov, I., Gokhberg, L., Thurner, T. and Khabirova, E., (2018). The Current State of the Russian Agricultural Sector. Eurochoices, 17(1), pp. 52–57, doi: 10.1111/1746-692X.12184. (In Russ.)Litvinenko, I.L., Solovykh, N.N., Smirnova, I.A., Kiyanova, L.D. and Mironova, O.A., (2019). The role of Agritourism clusters in implementing the concept of sustainable development region. Dilemas contemporaneos-educacion politica y valores, 6(3), pp.71. (In Russ.)Litvinenko, I.L., Solovykh, N.N., Smirnova, I.A., Kiyanova, L.D. and Mironova, O.A., (2019). The role of Agritourism clusters in implementing the concept of sustainable development region. Dilemas contemporaneos-educacion politica y valores, 6(3), pp.71. (In Russ.)Lobachevskiy, Ya.P., Starovoytov, S.I., Akhalaya, B.Kh. and Tsench, Yu.S., (2019). Digital technologies in tillage. Agricultural innovations, 1, pp. 191–197. (In Russ.)Lobachevskiy, Ya.P., Starovoytov, S.I., Akhalaya, B.Kh. and Tsench, Yu.S., (2019). Digital technologies in tillage. Agricultural innovations, 1, pp. 191–197. (In Russ.)Loginova, D.A. and Strokov, A.S., (2019). Institutional issues of sustainable development in rural areas ofRussia. Public Administration Issues, 2, pp. 115–140. (In Russ.)Loginova, D.A. and Strokov, A.S., (2019). Institutional issues of sustainable development in rural areas ofRussia. Public Administration Issues, 2, pp. 115–140. (In Russ.)Lut, O.N., (2019). Development of the social sphere of the village. Analytical Bulletin of the Federation Council of the Federal Assembly of the Russian Federation, 5, pp. 11–12. (In Russ.)Lut, O.N., (2019). Development of the social sphere of the village. Analytical Bulletin of the Federation Council of the Federal Assembly of the Russian Federation, 5, pp. 11–12. (In Russ.)Mikhaylov, A.V., (2019). Legal ways to suppress unfair competition in the organic market. Competition Law, 3, pp. 37–39. (In Russ.)Mikhaylov, A.V., (2019). Legal ways to suppress unfair competition in the organic market. Competition Law, 3, pp. 37–39. (In Russ.)Minina, E.L., (2017). Legal support for the development of agriculture in the Far East. Journal of Russian Law, 6, pp. 134–144, doi: 10.12737/article_59240612b42d52.36179719. (In Russ.)Minina, E.L., (2017). Legal support for the development of agriculture in the Far East. Journal of Russian Law, 6, pp. 134–144, doi: 10.12737/article_59240612b42d52.36179719. (In Russ.)Mironova, S.M., Chikildina, A.Yu., (2016). Features of the provision of land plots in the Far East: topical issues of legal regulation. Actual Problems of Russian Law, 7, pp. 42–49. (In Russ.)Mironova, S.M., Chikildina, A.Yu., (2016). Features of the provision of land plots in the Far East: topical issues of legal regulation. Actual Problems of Russian Law, 7, pp. 42–49. (In Russ.)Nemenushchaya, L.A., (2019). Digital technologies in phytopathology. Agricultural Innovations, 1, pp. 215–221. (In Russ.)Nemenushchaya, L.A., (2019). Digital technologies in phytopathology. Agricultural Innovations, 1, pp. 215–221. (In Russ.)Polushkina, T.M., (2016). Sustainable development of rural areas through the formation of organic agriculture. National Interests: Priorities and Security, 12(6), pp. 22–32. (In Russ.)Polushkina, T.M., (2016). Sustainable development of rural areas through the formation of organic agriculture. National Interests: Priorities and Security, 12(6), pp. 22–32. (In Russ.)Popova, O.V., (2018). Problems oflegal regulation ofdigitalization in the agro-industrial complex. Agrarian and Land Law, 9, p. 96. (In Russ.)Popova, O.V., (2018). Problems oflegal regulation ofdigitalization in the agro-industrial complex. Agrarian and Land Law, 9, p. 96. (In Russ.)Report on the state and use of agricultural land in the Russian Federation in 2017. (2019). Moscow: FGBNU “Rosinformagrotech”. P. 26. (In Russ.)Report on the state and use of agricultural land in the Russian Federation in 2017. (2019). Moscow: FGBNU “Rosinformagrotech”. P. 26. (In Russ.)Rumyantsev, F.P. and Konopleva, T.D., (2016). Will the new law ensure the implementation of the Address of the President of the Russian Federation on the withdrawal of unused agricultural land? Property Relations in the Russian Federation, 9, p. 89. (In Russ.)Rumyantsev, F.P. and Konopleva, T.D., (2016). Will the new law ensure the implementation of the Address of the President of the Russian Federation on the withdrawal of unused agricultural land? Property Relations in the Russian Federation, 9, p. 89. (In Russ.)Shagayda, N.I. and Uzun V.Ya., (2019). Drivers of growth and structural shifts in agriculture in Russia. Moscow: Izdatelskij dom “Delo”, RANHiGS. P. 31. (In Russ.)Shagayda, N.I. and Uzun V.Ya., (2019). Drivers of growth and structural shifts in agriculture in Russia. Moscow: Izdatelskij dom “Delo”, RANHiGS. P. 31. (In Russ.)Skvortsov, E.A., Skvortsova, E.G, Sandu, I.S. and Iovlev, G.A., (2018). The transition of agriculture to digital, intelligent and robotic technologies. Economy of Region, 3, pp. 1014–1015. (In Russ.)Skvortsov, E.A., Skvortsova, E.G, Sandu, I.S. and Iovlev, G.A., (2018). The transition of agriculture to digital, intelligent and robotic technologies. Economy of Region, 3, pp. 1014–1015. (In Russ.)Volkov, G.A., (2006). The concept of the Federal law on the regulation of property relations arising from the privatization of agricultural land. Environmental Law, 4, p. 10. (In Russ.)Volkov, G.A., (2006). The concept of the Federal law on the regulation of property relations arising from the privatization of agricultural land. Environmental Law, 4, p. 10. (In Russ.)Voronin, B.A., (2013). On the issue of legal regulation of the development of the market for organic agricultural products in the Russian Federation. Agrarian Bulletin of the Urals, 9, pp. 80–83. (In Russ.)Voronin, B.A., (2013). On the issue of legal regulation of the development of the market for organic agricultural products in the Russian Federation. Agrarian Bulletin of the Urals, 9, pp. 80–83. (In Russ.)Voronina, N.P., (2016). To the question of the concept and content of the model of legal regulation of the creation and operation of agricultural cooperatives. Fundamental and applied research of cooperative sector of the economy, 2, pp. 3–7. (In Russ.)Voronina, N.P., (2016). To the question of the concept and content of the model of legal regulation of the creation and operation of agricultural cooperatives. Fundamental and applied research of cooperative sector of the economy, 2, pp. 3–7. (In Russ.)Voronina, N.P., (2019). Production and export of organic products as a strategic task of the Russian state. Agrarian and Land Law, 6, pp. 34–38. (In Russ.)Voronina, N.P., (2019). Production and export of organic products as a strategic task of the Russian state. Agrarian and Land Law, 6, pp. 34–38. (In Russ.)Voronina, N.P., (2020). Digital agriculture in Russia: directions for improving legal regulation. Ius Publicum et Privatum, 4, p. 19. (In Russ.)Voronina, N.P., (2020). Digital agriculture in Russia: directions for improving legal regulation. Ius Publicum et Privatum, 4, p. 19. (In Russ.)Voronina, N.P., (2021). Legal regulation of innovations in entrepreneurial activity in the field of agriculture. In: Vaypan, V.A., Egorova, M.A. (eds). (2021). Modern problems of the development of business and corporate law in Russia and abroad. Moscow: Yustitsinform. Pp. 94–108. (In Russ.)Voronina, N.P., (2021). Legal regulation of innovations in entrepreneurial activity in the field of agriculture. In: Vaypan, V.A., Egorova, M.A. (eds). (2021). Modern problems of the development of business and corporate law in Russia and abroad. Moscow: Yustitsinform. Pp. 94–108. (In Russ.)Voronina, N.P., Shnorr, Zh.P. (2019). Digitalization ofagriculture: problems of legal support. European Proceedings of Social and Behavioural Sciences EpSBS, p. 950. (In Russ.)Voronina, N.P., Shnorr, Zh.P. (2019). Digitalization ofagriculture: problems of legal support. European Proceedings of Social and Behavioural Sciences EpSBS, p. 950. (In Russ.)Vronskaya, M.V. and Krivtsova, K.E., (2018). Legal regime of the “Far Eastern hectare: topical problems of its regulation and implementation”. Administrative and Municipal Law, 11, pp. 1–10, doi: 10.7256/2454-0595.2018.11.28105. (In Russ.)Vronskaya, M.V. and Krivtsova, K.E., (2018). Legal regime of the “Far Eastern hectare: topical problems of its regulation and implementation”. Administrative and Municipal Law, 11, pp. 1–10, doi: 10.7256/2454-0595.2018.11.28105. (In Russ.)Yurina, N.N., (2018). Directions of digitalization of agriculture in Russia. Bulletin of the Institute of Economics and Management of NovSU, 2, p. 95. (In Russ.)Yurina, N.N., (2018). Directions of digitalization of agriculture in Russia. Bulletin of the Institute of Economics and Management of NovSU, 2, p. 95. (In Russ.)Zadvorneva, E.P., (2018). Digitization ofagriculture in Kazakhstan as a vector of innovative development of the industry infrastructure. Regional problems of economic transformation: integration processes and mechanisms of formation and socio-economic policy of the region. Proceedings of the 9th International Conference, p. 349. (In Russ.)Zadvorneva, E.P., (2018). Digitization ofagriculture in Kazakhstan as a vector of innovative development of the industry infrastructure. Regional problems of economic transformation: integration processes and mechanisms of formation and socio-economic policy of the region. Proceedings of the 9th International Conference, p. 349. (In Russ.)Zanilov, A.Kh., Melenteva, O.S. and Nakaryakov, A.M., (2021). Scientific and methodological recommendations for agricultural consultants “Organization of organic agricultural production in Russia.” Moscow: Organic Farming Union. Available at: https://soz. bio/organizaciya-organicheskogo-selskohozyajstvennogo-proizvodstvav-rossii/ [Accessed 20.05.2021]. (In Russ.)Zanilov, A.Kh., Melenteva, O.S. and Nakaryakov, A.M., (2021). Scientific and methodological recommendations for agricultural consultants “Organization of organic agricultural production in Russia.” Moscow: Organic Farming Union. Available at: https://soz. bio/organizaciya-organicheskogo-selskohozyajstvennogo-proizvodstvav-rossii/ [Accessed 20.05.2021]. (In Russ.)

The authors declare that there are no conflicts of interest present.