kulawrKutafin Law ReviewKutafin Law Review2713-05252713-0533MSAL10.17803/2313-5395.2022.4.22.641-663kulawr-184Research ArticleHUMANISM, JUDICIARY, CORRUPTION PREVENTIONJudiciary and Civil Society in Provision of Constitutional Rule of Law in the Russian Federationhttps://orcid.org/0000-0001-7012-0727SkuratovYu. I.

Yurij I. Skuratov, Dr. Sci. (Law), Professor, Head of the Department of Constitutional and International Law,

65 Leninsky prospekt, Room 327, Moscow 119991

corpuscivilis@mail.ruhttps://orcid.org/0000-0001-6629-1128YastrebovaA. I.

Anna I. Yastrebova, Cand. Sci. (Law), Associate Professor, Department of Constitutional and International Law, 

65 Leninsky prospekt, Room 327, Moscow 119991

ann-yastr@mail.ruhttps://orcid.org/0000-0001-5411-6349DzhavakhyanR. M.

Roman M. Dzhavakhyan, Cand. Sci. (Law), Associate Professor, Department of Legal Support for Civil and Municipal Services,

82 prospekt Vernadskogo, Moscow 119571

corpuscivilis@mail.ruNational University of Oil and Gas “Gubkin University”Russian FederationRussian Presidential Academy of National Economy and Public AdministrationRussian Federation20220201202394641663Copyright © Skuratov Y.I., Yastrebova A.I., Dzhavakhyan R.M., 20232023Skuratov Y.I., Yastrebova A.I., Dzhavakhyan R.M.Skuratov Y.I., Yastrebova A.I., Dzhavakhyan R.M.Данная работа распространяется под лицензией Creative Commons Attribution 4.0.This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.https://kulawr.msal.ru/jour/article/view/184

The existing demand for ensuring constitutional legal order as an indicator of the embodiment of law and legality in the regulation of social relations, the role of the judiciary and civil society institutions in achieving the supremacy of the Constitution as the most important condition for the formation of a constitutional state testify to the relevance of the chosen topic of research. The article is aimed at developing conceptual positions on the relationship of various public institutions (state and non-state) in the framework of ensuring justice as the most important guarantee of the rights and freedoms of citizens, their associations, a fundamental condition for ensuring and maintaining constitutional legal order. The study of the role of the judiciary in its dialectical relationship with the institutions of civil society, in the formation and maintenance of the constitutional legal order was used as the main approach for the research of the selected problems. The application of systemic and structural-functional methods of research provided an opportunity to consider the issues of constitutional legal order as a holistic phenomenon, which is in direct dependence on the associated systems of the judiciary and civil society. The analysis of the norms of the Constitution of the Russian Federation, the current legislation of Russia, domestic and foreign scientific publications on judicial power and its interaction with institutions of civil society made it possible to receive the scientific information on the nature of influence of these constitutional and legal institutes on maintenance of the constitutional legal order. There is a need to increase the level of constitutionalization of legal regulation of public relations in the specified sphere, aimed to guarantee the effective realization of the principle of people's authority. The results and conclusions presented in the article can be used for the purposes of improvement legal and regulatory framework for social relations in the spheres of relations between the judiciary and civil society in their aim to achieve and maintain constitutional legal order. The obtained scientific information can be used in the educational process, as well as a basis for further theoretical research in the field of problems of Russian constitutionalism. 

Constitutioncitizensconstitutional rightsfreedoms of citizensconstitutional guaranteesconstitution supremacyconstitutional rule of lawConstitutional Court of the Russian Federationpublic institutionsjudiciaryjudicial community bodiescivil societyadvocacyReferencesAnishina, V.I. and Gadzhiev, G.A., (2006). Independence of the judiciary. Obshchestvennye nauki i sovremennost [Social Sciences and Contemporary World], 6, pp. 5–14. (In Russ.).Anishina, V.I. and Gadzhiev, G.A., (2006). Independence of the judiciary. Obshchestvennye nauki i sovremennost [Social Sciences and Contemporary World], 6, pp. 5–14. (In Russ.).Baranov, P.P., (2014). Modern Problems of the Theory of Constitutional Law and Order in the Russian Federation. Filosofiya prava [Philosophy of Law], 4(65), pp. 95–101. (In Russ.).Baranov, P.P., (2014). Modern Problems of the Theory of Constitutional Law and Order in the Russian Federation. Filosofiya prava [Philosophy of Law], 4(65), pp. 95–101. (In Russ.).Barber, N.W. and Vermeule, A., (2016). The Exceptional Role of Courts in the Constitutional Order. Harvard Public Law Working Paper, 16–25. Posted: 18 February 2016. Available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2734218, doi: 10.2139/ssrn.2734218.Barber, N.W. and Vermeule, A., (2016). The Exceptional Role of Courts in the Constitutional Order. Harvard Public Law Working Paper, 16–25. Posted: 18 February 2016. Available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2734218, doi: 10.2139/ssrn.2734218.Barber, N.W., (2001). Prelude to the Separation of Powers. Cambridge Law Journal, 60, pp. 59–88. Available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2240838 [Accessed 14.11.2022].Barber, N.W., (2001). Prelude to the Separation of Powers. Cambridge Law Journal, 60, pp. 59–88. Available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2240838 [Accessed 14.11.2022].Berdnikova, E.V., (2012). Forms of public control in the judicial system of the Russian Federation. Izvestiya Saratovskogo universiteta, Seriya: Ekonomika, Upravlenie, Pravo, 12(1), pp. 97–101. (In Russ.).Berdnikova, E.V., (2012). Forms of public control in the judicial system of the Russian Federation. Izvestiya Saratovskogo universiteta, Seriya: Ekonomika, Upravlenie, Pravo, 12(1), pp. 97–101. (In Russ.).Bezrukov, A.V. and Teplyashin, I.V., (2018). The Role of the Public in Strengthening Constitutional Law and Order in Russia. Russian Law: Education, Practice, Science, 3, pp. 36–40. (In Russ.).Bezrukov, A.V. and Teplyashin, I.V., (2018). The Role of the Public in Strengthening Constitutional Law and Order in Russia. Russian Law: Education, Practice, Science, 3, pp. 36–40. (In Russ.).Bezrukov, A.V., (2017). Constitutional and legal mechanism for ensuring law and order by public authorities in the Russian Federation. The Author’s Summary of Dr. Sci. (Law) Diss. Ural State Law Academy. Ekaterinburg. (In Russ.).Bezrukov, A.V., (2017). Constitutional and legal mechanism for ensuring law and order by public authorities in the Russian Federation. The Author’s Summary of Dr. Sci. (Law) Diss. Ural State Law Academy. Ekaterinburg. (In Russ.).Bondar, N.S., (2010). Constitutional Court of Russia: Not a “quasicourt”, but more than a court. Zhurnal konstitucionnogo pravosudiya [Journal of Constitutional Justice], 3(15), pp. 28–33. (In Russ.).Bondar, N.S., (2010). Constitutional Court of Russia: Not a “quasicourt”, but more than a court. Zhurnal konstitucionnogo pravosudiya [Journal of Constitutional Justice], 3(15), pp. 28–33. (In Russ.).Dzhavakhyan, R.M., (2017). Improvement of forms of citizen participation in the administration of justice as a mechanism of constitutional transformation of the judiciary. Russian Juridical Journal, 2, pp. 45–54. (In Russ.).Dzhavakhyan, R.M., (2017). Improvement of forms of citizen participation in the administration of justice as a mechanism of constitutional transformation of the judiciary. Russian Juridical Journal, 2, pp. 45–54. (In Russ.).Dzhavakhyan, R.M., (2018). Constitutional justice, arbitration proceedings and the right to judicial protection. Moscow: De’Libri Publ. (In Russ.).Dzhavakhyan, R.M., (2018). Constitutional justice, arbitration proceedings and the right to judicial protection. Moscow: De’Libri Publ. (In Russ.).Dzhavakhyan, R.M., (2020). Judicial Power: In Search of Constitutional Balance. Modern Law, 3, pp. 5–14. (In Russ.).Dzhavakhyan, R.M., (2020). Judicial Power: In Search of Constitutional Balance. Modern Law, 3, pp. 5–14. (In Russ.).Ebzeev, B.S., (2014). Constitution, power and freedom in Russia: The experience of synthetic research. Moscow: Prospekt Publ. (In Russ.).Ebzeev, B.S., (2014). Constitution, power and freedom in Russia: The experience of synthetic research. Moscow: Prospekt Publ. (In Russ.).Faroi, T.V., (2018). Qualification collegiums of judges and the problem of the independence of the judiciary in the Russian Federation. Vestnik Tomskoy gosudarstvennoy akademii, 15(2), pp. 130–136. (In Russ.).Faroi, T.V., (2018). Qualification collegiums of judges and the problem of the independence of the judiciary in the Russian Federation. Vestnik Tomskoy gosudarstvennoy akademii, 15(2), pp. 130–136. (In Russ.).Flyvbjerg, B., (1998). Habermas and Foucault: Thinkers for Civil Society? The British Journal of Sociology, 49(2), pp. 210–233. Available at: http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2237923.Flyvbjerg, B., (1998). Habermas and Foucault: Thinkers for Civil Society? The British Journal of Sociology, 49(2), pp. 210–233. Available at: http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2237923.Golovistikova, A.N. and Grudtsyna, L.Y., (2007). Explanatory dictionary of legal terms. Moscow: Eksmo Publ. (In Russ.).Golovistikova, A.N. and Grudtsyna, L.Y., (2007). Explanatory dictionary of legal terms. Moscow: Eksmo Publ. (In Russ.).Guk, P.A., (2009). Review of Proceedings of the Round Table Legal Policy and Legal Reform in Modern Russia. Gosudarstvo i pravo [State and Law], 4, pp. 106–107. (In Russ.).Guk, P.A., (2009). Review of Proceedings of the Round Table Legal Policy and Legal Reform in Modern Russia. Gosudarstvo i pravo [State and Law], 4, pp. 106–107. (In Russ.).Khabrieva, T.Y. and Chirkin, V.E., (2005). Theory of the Modern Constitution. Moscow: Norma Publ. (In Russ.).Khabrieva, T.Y. and Chirkin, V.E., (2005). Theory of the Modern Constitution. Moscow: Norma Publ. (In Russ.).Kokotov, A.N., (2018). Action and realization of the Constitution of Russia of 1993. Vestnik Sibirskogo yuridicheskogo instituta MVD Rossii, 4(33), pp. 14–20. (In Russ.).Kokotov, A.N., (2018). Action and realization of the Constitution of Russia of 1993. Vestnik Sibirskogo yuridicheskogo instituta MVD Rossii, 4(33), pp. 14–20. (In Russ.).Law, D.S., (2009). A Theory of Judicial Power and Judicial Review (December 20, 2008). Georgetown Law Journal, 97, p. 723. Available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1112613 [Accessed 14.11.2022].Law, D.S., (2009). A Theory of Judicial Power and Judicial Review (December 20, 2008). Georgetown Law Journal, 97, p. 723. Available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1112613 [Accessed 14.11.2022].Leist, O.E., (2002). The essence of law. Problems of theory and philosophy of law. Moscow: Zertsalo-M Publ. (In Russ.).Leist, O.E., (2002). The essence of law. Problems of theory and philosophy of law. Moscow: Zertsalo-M Publ. (In Russ.).Lipchanskaya, M.A., (2012). Participation of citizens in the management of state affairs: Constitutional and legal research. The The Author's Summary of Dr. Sci. (Law) Diss. (In Russ.).Lipchanskaya, M.A., (2012). Participation of citizens in the management of state affairs: Constitutional and legal research. The The Author's Summary of Dr. Sci. (Law) Diss. (In Russ.).Lyadnova, E.V., (2010). The right of citizens to participate in the administration of justice: constitutional and legal content and mechanism of implementation. The Author's Summary of Cand. Sci. (Law) Diss. Belgorod State University. Belgorod. (In Russ.).Lyadnova, E.V., (2010). The right of citizens to participate in the administration of justice: constitutional and legal content and mechanism of implementation. The Author's Summary of Cand. Sci. (Law) Diss. Belgorod State University. Belgorod. (In Russ.).Matuzov, N.I. and Malko, A.V., (2006). Theory of State and Law. Moscow: Yurist Publ. (In Russ.).Matuzov, N.I. and Malko, A.V., (2006). Theory of State and Law. Moscow: Yurist Publ. (In Russ.).Mishin, A.A., (1984). The principle of separation of powers in the US constitutional mechanism. Moscow: Publishing House “Nauka”. (In Russ.).Mishin, A.A., (1984). The principle of separation of powers in the US constitutional mechanism. Moscow: Publishing House “Nauka”. (In Russ.).Montesquieu, S., (1955). On the Spirit of Laws: Selected Works. Moscow: Goslitizdat Publ. (In Russ.).Montesquieu, S., (1955). On the Spirit of Laws: Selected Works. Moscow: Goslitizdat Publ. (In Russ.).Narutto, S.V., (2018). The supremacy of the Constitution as the basis of the constitutional legal order in Russia. Russian Law: Education, Practice, Science, 3, pp. 30–33. (In Russ.).Narutto, S.V., (2018). The supremacy of the Constitution as the basis of the constitutional legal order in Russia. Russian Law: Education, Practice, Science, 3, pp. 30–33. (In Russ.).Neves, I.F., (2019). Hermeneutical possibilities to the judicial appreciation of administrative unconstitutional omissions: the control of unconstitutional omissions in contemporary constitutionalism. Quaestio Iuris, 12(4), pp. 698–717, doi: 10.12957/rqi.2020.39212.Neves, I.F., (2019). Hermeneutical possibilities to the judicial appreciation of administrative unconstitutional omissions: the control of unconstitutional omissions in contemporary constitutionalism. Quaestio Iuris, 12(4), pp. 698–717, doi: 10.12957/rqi.2020.39212.Piatek, W., (2020). Access to the Highest Administrative Courts: between the Right of an Individual to Have a Case Heard and the Right of a Court to Hear Selected Cases. Central European Public Administration Review, 18(1), pp. 7–23, doi: 10.17573/cepar.2020.1.01.Piatek, W., (2020). Access to the Highest Administrative Courts: between the Right of an Individual to Have a Case Heard and the Right of a Court to Hear Selected Cases. Central European Public Administration Review, 18(1), pp. 7–23, doi: 10.17573/cepar.2020.1.01.Rakov, K.A., (2020). Key characteristics of the constitutional legal order. Vestnik Moskovskogo universiteta MVD Rossii, 1, pp. 20– 22. (In Russ.).Rakov, K.A., (2020). Key characteristics of the constitutional legal order. Vestnik Moskovskogo universiteta MVD Rossii, 1, pp. 20– 22. (In Russ.).Richards, N.M. and King, J., (2014). Big Data Ethics. Wake Forest Law Review, 19 May 2014. Available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2384174 [Accessed 14.11.2022].Richards, N.M. and King, J., (2014). Big Data Ethics. Wake Forest Law Review, 19 May 2014. Available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2384174 [Accessed 14.11.2022].Rubinina, E.R., (2015). Participation of civil society institutions in the administration of justice. Saratov State Law Academy Bulletin, 5(106), pp. 111–117. (In Russ.).Rubinina, E.R., (2015). Participation of civil society institutions in the administration of justice. Saratov State Law Academy Bulletin, 5(106), pp. 111–117. (In Russ.).Rzhevskij, V.A. and Chepurnova, N.M., (1998). Judicial Power in the Russian Federation: Constitutional Basis of Organization and Activity. Moscow: Yurist Publ. (In Russ.).Rzhevskij, V.A. and Chepurnova, N.M., (1998). Judicial Power in the Russian Federation: Constitutional Basis of Organization and Activity. Moscow: Yurist Publ. (In Russ.).Schor, M., (2006). The Rule of Law. Encyclopedia of Law and Society: American and Global Perspectives, Forthcoming. Suffolk University Law School Research Paper, No. 07-14. Posted: 27 Mar 2006. Available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=889472 [Accessed 14.11.2022].Schor, M., (2006). The Rule of Law. Encyclopedia of Law and Society: American and Global Perspectives, Forthcoming. Suffolk University Law School Research Paper, No. 07-14. Posted: 27 Mar 2006. Available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=889472 [Accessed 14.11.2022].Shah, B., (2020). Executive (Agency) Administration. Stanford Law Review, 72(3), pp. 641–747. Available at: https://www.stanfordlawreview.org/print/article/executive-agency-administration/ [Accessed 14.11.2022].Shah, B., (2020). Executive (Agency) Administration. Stanford Law Review, 72(3), pp. 641–747. Available at: https://www.stanfordlawreview.org/print/article/executive-agency-administration/ [Accessed 14.11.2022].Shinkarev, A.V., (2006). Social control in the system of law enforcement by internal affairs bodies. The Author's Summary of Cand. Sci. (Law) Diss. Moscow. (In Russ.).Shinkarev, A.V., (2006). Social control in the system of law enforcement by internal affairs bodies. The Author's Summary of Cand. Sci. (Law) Diss. Moscow. (In Russ.).Skuratov, Y.I., Glazkova, L.V., Grudinin, N.S., and Neznamova, A.A., (2016). The development of organized crime in Russia: A system analysis. Russian Journal of Criminology, 10(4), pp. 638–648, doi: 10.17150/2500-4255.2016.10(4).638-648. (In Russ.).Skuratov, Y.I., Glazkova, L.V., Grudinin, N.S., and Neznamova, A.A., (2016). The development of organized crime in Russia: A system analysis. Russian Journal of Criminology, 10(4), pp. 638–648, doi: 10.17150/2500-4255.2016.10(4).638-648. (In Russ.).Skuratov, Yu.I., (1996). Chapter 17. In: Kutafin, O.E., editor, (1996). State Law of the Russian Federation. Moscow: Juridicheskaya literatura Publ. (In Russ.).Skuratov, Yu.I., (1996). Chapter 17. In: Kutafin, O.E., editor, (1996). State Law of the Russian Federation. Moscow: Juridicheskaya literatura Publ. (In Russ.).Smirnova, V.A., (2006). The constitutional right of citizens to participate in the administration of justice. The Author's Summary of Cand. Sci. (Law) Diss. Dostoevsky Omsk State University. Omsk. (In Russ.).Smirnova, V.A., (2006). The constitutional right of citizens to participate in the administration of justice. The Author's Summary of Cand. Sci. (Law) Diss. Dostoevsky Omsk State University. Omsk. (In Russ.).Yastrebova, A.I., Salomatkin, A.S., Dzhavakhyan, R.M., Redkous, V.M., and Filonov, V.I., (2016). Civil Public Organizations for Providing a Public Order and their Role in Forming of Civil Society. Journal of Advanced Research in Law and Economics, Volume VII, 2(16), pp. 417–425. Available at: https://journals.aserspublishing.eu/jarle/article/view/229 [Accessed 14.11.2022].Yastrebova, A.I., Salomatkin, A.S., Dzhavakhyan, R.M., Redkous, V.M., and Filonov, V.I., (2016). Civil Public Organizations for Providing a Public Order and their Role in Forming of Civil Society. Journal of Advanced Research in Law and Economics, Volume VII, 2(16), pp. 417–425. Available at: https://journals.aserspublishing.eu/jarle/article/view/229 [Accessed 14.11.2022].Yastrebova, A.I., Stakhov, A.I., Merkulov, P.A., Suchkova, T.Y., Filonov, V.I., and Matveeva, E.S., (2017). Constitutional-legal and administrative-legal aspects of statutory regulation and maintenance of public security in the Russian Federation by the state and private actors. Journal of Advanced Research in Law and Economics, 8(1), pp. 272– 290. Available at: https://journals.aserspublishing.eu/jarle/article/view/1154 [Accessed 14.11.2022].Yastrebova, A.I., Stakhov, A.I., Merkulov, P.A., Suchkova, T.Y., Filonov, V.I., and Matveeva, E.S., (2017). Constitutional-legal and administrative-legal aspects of statutory regulation and maintenance of public security in the Russian Federation by the state and private actors. Journal of Advanced Research in Law and Economics, 8(1), pp. 272– 290. Available at: https://journals.aserspublishing.eu/jarle/article/view/1154 [Accessed 14.11.2022].Yastrebova, A.I., Stakhov, A.I., Redkous, V.M., Gubin, A.N., and Suchkova, T.Y., (2020). State and non-state actors ensuring constitutional order and public security: Problems of legal regulation of interaction. PalArch’s Journal of Archaeology of Egypt / Egyptology, 17(10), pp. 3424–3446. Available at: https://archives.palarch.nl/index.php/jae/article/view/5656/5556 [Accessed 14.11.2022].Yastrebova, A.I., Stakhov, A.I., Redkous, V.M., Gubin, A.N., and Suchkova, T.Y., (2020). State and non-state actors ensuring constitutional order and public security: Problems of legal regulation of interaction. PalArch’s Journal of Archaeology of Egypt / Egyptology, 17(10), pp. 3424–3446. Available at: https://archives.palarch.nl/index.php/jae/article/view/5656/5556 [Accessed 14.11.2022].

The authors declare that there are no conflicts of interest present.