kulawrKutafin Law ReviewKutafin Law Review2713-05252713-0533MSAL10.17803/2713-0533.2023.2.25.647-680kulawr-223Research ArticleLAW ENFORCEMENT AND NATIONAL PRACTICESEnsuring the Health of the Nation as a Determinant of Innovations in Law Enforcement and Judicial Activitieshttps://orcid.org/0009-0004-2210-1985OtcheskayaT. I.

Dr. Sci. (Law), Professor, Head of the Department of Organization of Judicial, Prosecution and Investigative Activities, Kutafin Moscow State Law University (MSAL)

9, Sadovaya-Kudrinskaya St., Moscow 125993

tiotcheskaya@msal.ruhttps://orcid.org/0000-0002-2293-7895AfanasyevaT. I.

Cand. Sci. (Law), Associate Professor, Department of Organization of Judicial, Prosecution and Investigative Activities9, Sadovaya-Kudrinskaya St., Moscow 125993

tiafanaseva@msal.ruhttps://orcid.org/0000-0003-3320-3093ZhukovaP. D.

Cand. Sci. (Law), Associate Professor, Department of Organization of Judicial, Prosecution and Investigative Activities

9, Sadovaya-Kudrinskaya St., Moscow 125993

pdshkurova@msal.ruhttps://orcid.org/0000-0003-0865-5645MishakovaN. V.

Cand. Sci. (Law), Associate Professor, D epartment of Organization of Judicial, Prosecution and Investigative Activities

9, Sadovaya-Kudrinskaya St., Moscow 125993

pdshkurova@msal.ruhttps://orcid.org/0009-0004-4458-6370OrkinaK. A.

Cand. Sci. (Law), Senior Lecturer, Department of Organization of Judicial, Prosecution and Investigative Activities, Kutafin Moscow State Law University (MSAL)

9, Sadovaya-Kudrinskaya St., Moscow 125993

orkina.kristina@bk.ruhttps://orcid.org/0009-0003-1260-440XShtefanD. I.

Lecturer, Department of Organization of Judicial, Prosecution and Investigative Activities, Kutafin Moscow State Law University (MSAL); Legal Adviser, Legal Support Department, Moscow Department of Healthcare

9, Sadovaya-Kudrinskaya St., Moscow 125993

dishtefan@msal.ruKutafin Moscow State Law University (MSAL)Russian Federation202311102023103647680Copyright © Otcheskaya T.I., Afanasyeva T.I., Zhukova P.D., Mishakova N.V., Orkina K.A., Shtefan D.I., 20232023Otcheskaya T.I., Afanasyeva T.I., Zhukova P.D., Mishakova N.V., Orkina K.A., Shtefan D.I.Otcheskaya T.I., Afanasyeva T.I., Zhukova P.D., Mishakova N.V., Orkina K.A., Shtefan D.I.Данная работа распространяется под лицензией Creative Commons Attribution 4.0.This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.https://kulawr.msal.ru/jour/article/view/223

The Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation has repeatedly stated the extreme importance of human life and health as values without which all other benefits lose their relevance. Despite this approach, practicing law upholders and law-makers are constantly faced with a dilemma between ensuring the human health and following public interests in a different dimension of the state activity. The purpose of this paper is 1) to substantiate the system-forming role of such vital values as preservation of human life and health in law-making and law enforcement, and 2) to determine the vector of legal regulation in the field of public health protection. The authors have analyzed the transformation of the legal regulation of relations aimed at ensuring the health of the nation in a number of key areas: the health of minors, high-tech medicine, the balance of interests of a doctor and a patient in law enforcement, digitalization of medicine and its impact on relations in the field of personal data protection, artificial intelligence in medicine, advanced legal regulation of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation in the field of healthcare. Based on the Russian and foreign legislation, the practice of the courts of the highest instance and the lower courts, the authors have proved a determinative influence of the constitutional obligation of the state to ensure the rights to life and health on the legal regulation and law enforcement. Proposals have been made concerning the need to finalize legal acts aimed at detailing the regulation of issues in these key areas.

health protectionhigh-tech medicinebreakthrough medical technologiespersonal data protectiondigitalization of medicineartificial intelligence in medicineiatrogenic crimesmedical errorbalance of interests of the doctor and patientadvanced legal regulationThe study was carried out within the framework of “Priority-2030” Strategic Academic Leadership Program.ReferencesAkca, S.O., Akpinar, Y.Y., and Habbani, T., (2015). Knowledge and Attitudes of Nurses Regarding Patient Rights: A Corum/Turkey Sample. Revista da Asociacao Medica Brasileira, 61 (5), pp. 452–457.Akca, S.O., Akpinar, Y.Y., and Habbani, T., (2015). Knowledge and Attitudes of Nurses Regarding Patient Rights: A Corum/Turkey Sample. Revista da Asociacao Medica Brasileira, 61 (5), pp. 452–457.Beskaravainaya, T., (2022). Russians complain more often about the poor quality and low availability of medical care. Medvestnik. 5 De- cember. Available at: https://medvestnik.ru/content/news/Rossiyane-stali-chashe-jalovatsya-na-plohoe-kachestvo-i-nizkuu-dostupnost-med-pomoshi.html [Accessed 12.02.2023]. (In Russ.).Beskaravainaya, T., (2022). Russians complain more often about the poor quality and low availability of medical care. Medvestnik. 5 De- cember. Available at: https://medvestnik.ru/content/news/Rossiyane-stali-chashe-jalovatsya-na-plohoe-kachestvo-i-nizkuu-dostupnost-med-pomoshi.html [Accessed 12.02.2023]. (In Russ.).Chauhan, Ch., (2013). India shamed by high child mortality rate. Hindustan Times, 22 September. Available at: https://www.hindustantimes.com/delhi/india-shamed-by-high-child-mortality-rate/story-gzJLkEgYj2X6VVUGaAMqUJ.html [Accessed 20.06.2023].Chauhan, Ch., (2013). India shamed by high child mortality rate. Hindustan Times, 22 September. Available at: https://www.hindustantimes.com/delhi/india-shamed-by-high-child-mortality-rate/story-gzJLkEgYj2X6VVUGaAMqUJ.html [Accessed 20.06.2023].Chicherin, L.P., (2013). Medical and psychological assistance to children and adolescents at the outpatient stage: difficulties of formation and prospects. Bulletin of the Research Institute of Public Health of the Russian Academy of Medical Sciences, 1, pp. 32–36.Chicherin, L.P., (2013). Medical and psychological assistance to children and adolescents at the outpatient stage: difficulties of formation and prospects. Bulletin of the Research Institute of Public Health of the Russian Academy of Medical Sciences, 1, pp. 32–36.Forcier, M.B., Gallois, H., Siobhan, M., and Yann, J., (2019). Integrating artificial intelligence into health care through data access: Can the GDPR act as a beacon for policymakers? Journal of Law and the Biosciences, 6(1), pp. 317–335, doi: 10.1093/jlb/lsz013.Forcier, M.B., Gallois, H., Siobhan, M., and Yann, J., (2019). Integrating artificial intelligence into health care through data access: Can the GDPR act as a beacon for policymakers? Journal of Law and the Biosciences, 6(1), pp. 317–335, doi: 10.1093/jlb/lsz013.Ivanova, A.P., (2021). Legal problems of the use of artificial intelligence in healthcare. Social Sciences and Humanities. Domestic and Foreign Literature. Series 4: State and Law: Abstract Journal, 1, pp. 151–159, doi: 10.31249/rgpravo/2021.01.16.Ivanova, A.P., (2021). Legal problems of the use of artificial intelligence in healthcare. Social Sciences and Humanities. Domestic and Foreign Literature. Series 4: State and Law: Abstract Journal, 1, pp. 151–159, doi: 10.31249/rgpravo/2021.01.16.Kamensky, S., (2020). Artificial Intelligence and Technology in Health Care: Overview and Possible Legal Implications. DePaul journal of health care law, 21(3), pp. 1–18. Available at: https://via.library.depaul.edu/jhcl/vol21/iss3/3 [Accessed 20.06.2023]. (In Russ.).Kamensky, S., (2020). Artificial Intelligence and Technology in Health Care: Overview and Possible Legal Implications. DePaul journal of health care law, 21(3), pp. 1–18. Available at: https://via.library.depaul.edu/jhcl/vol21/iss3/3 [Accessed 20.06.2023]. (In Russ.).Kartskhiya, A.A., (2021). A modern challenge of the digital healthcare emergence. Law and Digital Economy, 3, pp. 39–46, doi: 10.17803/2618-8198.2021.13.3.039-046. (In Russ.).Kartskhiya, A.A., (2021). A modern challenge of the digital healthcare emergence. Law and Digital Economy, 3, pp. 39–46, doi: 10.17803/2618-8198.2021.13.3.039-046. (In Russ.).Linnard-Palmer, L. and Kools, S., (2004). Parents’ refusal of medical treatment based on religious and/or cultural beliefs: The law, ethical principles, and clinical implications. Journal of Pediatric Nursing, 19(5), pp. 351–356, doi: 10.1016/j.pedn.2004.05.014.Linnard-Palmer, L. and Kools, S., (2004). Parents’ refusal of medical treatment based on religious and/or cultural beliefs: The law, ethical principles, and clinical implications. Journal of Pediatric Nursing, 19(5), pp. 351–356, doi: 10.1016/j.pedn.2004.05.014.Lopatina, T.M., (2019). Professional Error in the Functioning of Digital Medicine. Russian Law: Education, Practice, Researches, 5(113), pp. 68–75, doi: 10.34076/2410-2709-2019-5-68-75. (In Russ.).Lopatina, T.M., (2019). Professional Error in the Functioning of Digital Medicine. Russian Law: Education, Practice, Researches, 5(113), pp. 68–75, doi: 10.34076/2410-2709-2019-5-68-75. (In Russ.).Maklakov, V.V., (2003). Constitutions of Foreign States. 4th ed. Moscow: Walters Kluwer Publ. (In Russ.). Sadovnikova, N.A., Polyakov, B.A., Mushnikov, D.L., and Shultz, S.V., (2015). Issues of implementation of the principle of health protection — “Priority of children’s health protection” at the municipal level. Bulletin of Semashko National Research Institute of Public Health, 1, pp. 166– 169. (In Russ.).Maklakov, V.V., (2003). Constitutions of Foreign States. 4th ed. Moscow: Walters Kluwer Publ. (In Russ.). Sadovnikova, N.A., Polyakov, B.A., Mushnikov, D.L., and Shultz, S.V., (2015). Issues of implementation of the principle of health protection — “Priority of children’s health protection” at the municipal level. Bulletin of Semashko National Research Institute of Public Health, 1, pp. 166– 169. (In Russ.).Sazhneva, E., (2022). Medical Error: Examination was taken away from the doctors. The expert essessed the important decision of the Head of the RF IC Alexander Bastrykin. MKRU. 3 November. Available at: https://www.mk.ru/social/2022/11/03/vrachebnaya-oshibka-u-me-dikov-otnyali-ekspertizu.html [Accessed 12.02.2023]. (In Russ.).Sazhneva, E., (2022). Medical Error: Examination was taken away from the doctors. The expert essessed the important decision of the Head of the RF IC Alexander Bastrykin. MKRU. 3 November. Available at: https://www.mk.ru/social/2022/11/03/vrachebnaya-oshibka-u-me-dikov-otnyali-ekspertizu.html [Accessed 12.02.2023]. (In Russ.).Stepanov, S.K., (2021). Deconstruction of the legal personhood of artificial intelligence. Digital Law Journal, 2(2), 14–30, doi: 10.38044/2686-9136-2021-2-2-14-30.Stepanov, S.K., (2021). Deconstruction of the legal personhood of artificial intelligence. Digital Law Journal, 2(2), 14–30, doi: 10.38044/2686-9136-2021-2-2-14-30.Taranov, A.M., Vasilyeva, T.P., Chumakov, A.S., Likhova, I.N., Trofimov, V.V., Simkina, I.B., Kalashnikov, N.M., Frolova, T.I., and Tsyganova, O.A., (2004). Perfection medical and organizational approaches to the examination of the quality of medical services in the system of medical insurance. Information-Methodical Letter. Ivanovo. (In Russ.).Taranov, A.M., Vasilyeva, T.P., Chumakov, A.S., Likhova, I.N., Trofimov, V.V., Simkina, I.B., Kalashnikov, N.M., Frolova, T.I., and Tsyganova, O.A., (2004). Perfection medical and organizational approaches to the examination of the quality of medical services in the system of medical insurance. Information-Methodical Letter. Ivanovo. (In Russ.).Tikhomirov, Yu.A. and Nanba, S.B. (eds), (2019). The legal concept of robotization. Moscow: Prospect Publ., doi: 10.31085/9785392305650-2019-240. (In Russ.).Tikhomirov, Yu.A. and Nanba, S.B. (eds), (2019). The legal concept of robotization. Moscow: Prospect Publ., doi: 10.31085/9785392305650-2019-240. (In Russ.).Tretyakova, E.P., (2021). Using artificial intelligence in healthcare: Allocating liability and risks. Digital Law Journal, 2(4), 51–60, doi: 10.38044/2686-9136-2021-2-4-51-60.Tretyakova, E.P., (2021). Using artificial intelligence in healthcare: Allocating liability and risks. Digital Law Journal, 2(4), 51–60, doi: 10.38044/2686-9136-2021-2-4-51-60.Tsallagova, Z.B., (2001). Ethnopedagogical prescriptions for a healthy lifestyle. Public Education. 4, pp. 207–211. (In Russ.).Tsallagova, Z.B., (2001). Ethnopedagogical prescriptions for a healthy lifestyle. Public Education. 4, pp. 207–211. (In Russ.).Zapisnaya, T.V., (2020). On the concept of the development of the legal regulation of relationships in the national healthcare digitization sphere. Yurist, 5, pp. 69–74, doi: 10.18572/1812-3929-2021-5-69-74. (In Russ.).Zapisnaya, T.V., (2020). On the concept of the development of the legal regulation of relationships in the national healthcare digitization sphere. Yurist, 5, pp. 69–74, doi: 10.18572/1812-3929-2021-5-69-74. (In Russ.).

The authors declare that there are no conflicts of interest present.