Legal Status of Sports Referees: Legal Nature, Features, Problems
https://doi.org/10.17803/2713-0533.2023.2.24.377-403
Abstract
The paper is devoted to the content and specificity of the legal status of sports judges (sports referees) as one of the categories of active participants — subjects of sports. The paper dwells on underestimation of the role and importance of sports referees in general and in particular for specific kinds of sports. A sports referee is the most important and integral element of sports in any of its forms and at any level. Understanding of the status and ontology of the professional activity of a sports referee allows us to understand the nature of sports, its autonomy. The paper describes the essence of the concept and the legal status of sports referees, explains possible functional and instrumental roles of sports referees in detail. The authors highlight and explain existing determinants of the complexity of the concept and legal status of a sports referee and the peculiarities of the ontology of this profession. The paper shows the most pressing problems in the field of staffing positions of sports referees with qualified personnel. The paper suggests a detailed taxonomy of professional rights of sports referees noting that there is a complex and non-linear picture of the distribution of the recognition and significance of certain rights depending on specific jurisdictions. The authors define a specific ordering (order-forming and order-retaining) of the sports product, which is the integral result of refereeing and fulfilling by sports referees of other official powers.
About the Authors
I. V. Ponkin
Kutafi n Moscow State Law University (MSAL)
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
Igor V. Ponkin, Dr. Sci. (Law), Professor, Department of Administrative Law and Procedure
9 Sadovaya-Kudrinskaya St., Moscow 125993
A. I. Lapteva
Kutafi n Moscow State Law University (MSAL)
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
Alena I. Lapteva, Cand. Sci. (Law), Associate Professor, Department of Sports Law
9 Sadovaya-Kudrinskaya St., Moscow 125993
References
1. Aristov, E.V., (2016). Role and Importance of sport within Legal Dimension of Modern Welfare State. Teoriya i praktika fizicheskoy kultury [Theory and Practice of Physical Culture], 6, pp. 52–54. (In Russ.).
2. Beloff, M.J., Kerr, T., and Demetriou, M., (1999). Sports Law. Oxford: Hart Publishing.
3. Caddell, R., (2005). The Referee’s Liability for Catastrophic Sports Injuries: A UK Perspective. Marquette Sports Law Review, 15(2), pp. 415–424.
4. Chapron, T., (2005). L’arbitre et ses fonctions éthiques. L’éthique du sport en débat, 7(2), doi: 10.4000/ethiquepublique.1945.
5. Cordell, T., (2022). “Just not acceptable”: National referee, umpire shortage in youth sports fueled by harsh fan behavior: Loss of about 50,000 referees and umpires nationwide since the 2018–2019 season. Available at: https://www.news5cleveland.com/local-news/helpwanted-ohio/just-not-acceptable-national-referee-umpire-shortage-inyouth-sports-fueled-by-harsh-fan-behavior [Accessed 20.03.2023].
6. Descripteur des rôles de juges et d’arbitres sportifs en Europe, 2020. Lyon: Enhancing the skills of Sport Officials in Europe (ONSIDE).
7. Kellett, P. and Shilbury, D., (2007). Umpire Participation: Is Abuse Really the Issue? Sport Management Review, 10(3), pp. 209–229.
8. Kerr, R., (2017). Sport and technology. Manchester: Manchester University Press.
9. Koch, S., (2008), Liability of referees: An analysis of tort liability for wrong referee decisions, Dissertation, Law Faculty of the Victoria University of Wellington, Wellington.
10. Leveaux, R., (2009). Using Technology in Sport to Support Referee’s Decision Making. In: Knowledge Management and Innovation in Advancing Economies: Analyses and Solutions: Proceedings of the 13th International Business Information Management Association Conference. Marrakech: IBIMA. Pp. 1184–1191.
11. Mandico, M., (2018). La responsabilità nello sport: l’arbitro non arbitro. Available at: https://www.glistatigenerali.com/calcio_giustizia/la-responsabilita-nello-sport-larbitro-non-arbitro [Accessed 20.03.2023].
12. Marchi, F., (2022). Il Presidente Trentalange in conferenza stampa: “L’arbitro è uno sportivo al pari di un calciatore.” Available at: https://www.aia-figc.it/news/il-presidente-trentalange-in-conferenza-stampa-larbitro-e-uno-sportivo-al-pari-di-un-calciatore-19931 [Accesse d 20.03 2023].
13. Mayer, M., (2005). Stepping in to Step Out of Liability: The Proper Standard of Liability for Referees in Foreseeable Judgment-Call Situations. DePaul Journal of Sports Law, 3(1), pp. 54–102.
14. Mohamadinejad, A., Mirsafian, H., and Soltanhoseini, M., (2012). Study on civil liability of referees in the sport competitions. Journal of Human Sport and Exercise, 7(1), pp. S24–S34.
15. Ruiz Caballero, J.A., Navarro Valdivieso, M.E., Brito Ojeda, E.M., et al., (2010). Árbitro de fútbol: Arbitraje y juicio deportivo. Madrid: Editorial Dykinson.
16. Samuel, R.D., (2021). Referees: Developmental, performance, and training considerations. In: M. Bertollo, E. Filho, P. Terry (eds). Advancements in Mental Skills Training. Abingdon: Routledge. Pp. 249–267.
17. Shevchenko, O.A., (2014). International and Comparative Labor Law in Professional Sports. Moscow: Prospekt Publ. (In Russ.).
18. Shevchen ko, O.A., (2015). The legal doctrine of labor regulation in the field of professional sports and ways of its implementation in Russia. Moscow: Prospekt Publ. (In Russ.).
19. Skene, P., (2023). Sport’s ugly blind spot — abuse of officials. Club Respect Journal. S.d. Available at: https://clubrespect.org.au/sportsugly-blind-spot-abuse-of-officials-combined [Accessed 20.03.2023].
20. Soloviev, A.A., Ponkin, I.V., Redkina, A.I., and Shevchenko, O.A., (2017). Public Administration in Sports: Textbook for Masters. Ponkin, I.V. (ed.). Moscow: Buki Vedi Publ.; Sports Law Department of Kutafin Moscow State Law University. (In Russ.).
21. VerSteeg, R. and Maruncic, K., (2015). Instant replay: A contemporary legal analysis. Mississippi Sports Law Review, 4(2), pp. 153–273.
22. Wolin, M.T. and Lang, R.D., (2013). Legal Liability for Sports Referees in Today’s Litigious World — If You Can’t Kill the Ump then Sue Him. University of Denver Sports & Entertainment Law Journal, 15, pp. 83–110.
Review
Supporting agencies: The study was carried out within the framework of “Priority-2030” Strategic Academic Leadership Program.
For citations:
Ponkin I.V., Lapteva A.I. Legal Status of Sports Referees: Legal Nature, Features, Problems. Kutafin Law Review. 2023;10(2):377-403. https://doi.org/10.17803/2713-0533.2023.2.24.377-403
Views: 81
Email this article 